There are songs that are truly great (sellers) and remain favourites because of sheer presence, lyricism, presentation and, to be honest, being released in a time conducive to being a hit in the first place.
To be a "hit", as opposed to being an also-ran, cover versions need at least 3 of the above criteria to be successful again, sometimes more than the original, but often not.
I will keep adding to this list as covers come to mind, suggesting why they succeeded (sometimes better than the original).
Covered and transformed from psycho-pop to jazz-funk by
801
This next song has been copied by many artists, most better than the original.
(who sang it just as well
live)
Covered successfully by
Bryan Ferry at the right time (Lennon's death)
Covered and transformed from folk to heavy metal by
Judas Priest Transformed from their heavy metal back to folk by
Judas Priest
Covered respectfully but presented with more bombast by
Kiss
WAR PIGS by Black Sabbath (
great video!)
Covered with a twist by
CAKE Covered and transformed from rock to choral by
Rondellus
Covered, transformed and bettered by
Soft Cell
Covered and transformed from rock to indie by
DEVO Covered and transformed from rock to very indie by
The Ventures
Covered, transformed from folk to rock and bettered by
Jimi Hendrix
Covered (let's leave it at that) by
Peter Noone (Ex Herman's Hermits)
This is a rare example of a record company having faith in the early part of an artists career.
SPACE ODDITY Original acoustic version by David Bowie (1st release)
Covered, transformed and bettered (just) by
Bowie (2nd release)
Covered and bettered by
David Bowie (3rd release - the hit)
Covered and bettered by
Lulu Covered (remixed) many time by Bowie (to make better?) - one
here
Covered, bettered? and transformed from pop to rock by
Joe Cocker
This next song has been copied by many artists, none better than the original.
Covered and
only made more popular by
Metallica Covered badly (weird syncopation) by
Alunah
Covered and transformed by
Will Young (1st version)
Covered and transformed by
Will Young (2nd version - the hit)
Covered, bettered and transformed to pop by
Yazz
Covered identically but at the right time in the UK by
Cilla Black
Want some more varied
music?